On Sunday, November 9, the Albuquerque Journal published a John Trevor editorial cartoon depicting a donkey ostensibly representing the Democratic Party mascot standing behind Governor Elect Deb Haaland with the donkey waving a foam glove with one finger pointing up with the glove having the printed words on it “1st Native American Woman Governor”. A cowboy is depicted with the initials “NM” on his hat with a Zia symbol emblazed on the front of his shirt with the cowboy ostensibly representing the State of New Mexico. The Zia symbol is inaccurate in that it has 4 sets of bars of 3 bars in a cluster around the circle when there should be 4 bars in each of the cluster of bars around the circle. The NM cowboy appears taller than Haaland as he looks down on her with a furrowed brow on his face as he very sarcastically says to Haaland “YES, CONGRTUALTIONS ON THAT! NOW LETS TALK ABOUT OUR BEING 50TH ON THE TOTEM POLL …”
The Trevor cartoon was posted on my FACEBOOK page where I labeled it as being degrading and racist. It was a “cowboys and Indians” trope unbecoming of John Trevor and his work with the Albuquerque Journal. The reaction to the post was swift and true. Over seven days, according to my FACEBOOK “insights”, the post had 29,362 views, 16,336 viewers, 369 thumbs ups and 259 comments and 70 Shares. The overwhelming majority of the comments were supportive of the argument that the editorial cartoon was indeed racist. Many comments included a condemnation of the Albuquerque Journal and its biased reporting over many decades. A very small handful of comments suggested that there was nothing wrong with the cartoon nor the criticism towards Haaland and the Democratic Party.
INDIGENOUS JOURNALISTS ASSOCIATION DEMANDS APOLOGY
The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) supports Indigenous journalists, advocates for press freedom and promotes accurate, contextual coverage of Indigenous peoples and communities. On November 12, the Indigenous Journalists Association issued the following press release:
IJA condemns racist cartoon published by the Albuquerque Journal
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
11/12/2026
Media contact — ija@indigenousjournalists.org
“The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) condemns the Albuquerque Journal’s decision to publish an editorial cartoon by John Trever that relies on racist stereotypes to depict New Mexico Governor-elect Deb Haaland, a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna. The cartoon appeared in the Sunday, Nov. 8 print edition. IJA calls on the Journal to issue a public apology and explain how the cartoon was approved for publication.
The cartoon references a “totem pole” to turn Haaland’s Indigenous identity into a punch line. In doing so, the Journal incorrectly attributed a cultural practice of tribes in the Pacific Northwest to a Pueblo woman, and the practice itself was not properly characterized. That choice reinforces the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable.Totem poles serve a specific cultural purpose and should not be a punchline.
While political cartoonists have every right to scrutinize Haaland’s record, her policy proposals and the challenges facing New Mexico, the Journal’s editors are responsible for what they choose to publish. Readers deserve political commentary that holds public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures.
IJA urges the Journal to take the following steps:
- Publish an apology in print and online that names the racist stereotypes in the cartoon and takes responsibility for publishing it.
- Explain how the cartoon was approved and identify what editors will change in their review of cartoons and other opinion content.
- Provide opportunities to educate staff in order to report for the community it serves rather than further marginalizing the Indigenous community.
- Seek and utilize resources by IJA and other organizations. IJA provides newsroom training to ensure coverage of Indigenous issues, people and communities is accurate, ethical and culturally appropriate, through the Indigenous Media Initiative.
New Mexico and the Southwest are home to many Native communities and Indigenous people are among the Journal’s readers, sources and neighbors. They deserve the same care, accuracy and respect that every community should expect from its newspaper.
Read the full statement here: https://indigenousjournalists.org/…/ija-condemns…/
ALBUQUERQUE JOURNAL MANAGING EDITOR’S COLUMN
On November 14, the Albuquerque Journal published the following editorial opinion column by Managing Editor James Bennett on Page A-10:
EDITOR’S NOTES
BENNETT: Addressing Haaland editorial cartoon concerns
Drawing’s cultural implications deserve attention, and we’ll learn from feedback, criticism
BY James Bennett, managing editor of the Journal.
“Editorial cartoonist John Trever sends rough drafts to Journal Opinion Editor Ryan Boetel and me every Wednesday afternoon.
The 50-year veteran did the same thing last week. The drawing, which was published Nov. 8, depicted Democratic Gov.-elect Deb Haaland.
Text in the cartoon showed a supporter next to Haaland, waving a foam finger that said: “1st Native American Woman Governor.” Another character, with “NM” on his cowboy hat, replied: “Yes, congratulations on that. Now let’s talk about our being 50th on the totem pole…”
Trever’s weekly cartoon was similar to a column I wrote the morning after the election, celebrating the historic nature of Haaland’s victory. It also asked what she would do differently than Democratic Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham, whose eight years in New Mexico did not lift the state out of the basement in national ratings from education to healthcare.
The difference between Trever’s cartoon and my column? I did not use a throwaway line about a totem pole as a punch line.
His cartoon raised some eyebrows among readers, who emailed me about it. But that’s been par for the course for Trever through his half century at the Journal. He draws piercing cartoons that elicit reaction — good and bad.
This one, though, comes on the heels of Haaland’s historic election. Not many readers liked seeing the Journal pour cold water on the celebration.
“They were emphasizing that she was the first Native American woman elected governor,” the 83-year-old Trever said Friday, just before at event at Albuquerque’s Weems Gallery honoring his 50 years at the Journal. “My point was there’s something of a bigger concern — that the state is nearly last on every list that matters. That’s what she has to deal with — the state’s poor rankings. That was the bottom line of what I drew.”
The Indigenous Journalists Association, which labeled the cartoon as racist, was not very happy. They emailed me Thursday evening.
“The cartoon references a ‘totem pole’ to turn Haaland’s Indigenous identity into a punch line,” the group wrote in a letter to me. “In doing so, the Journal incorrectly attributed a cultural practice of tribes in the Pacific Northwest to a Pueblo woman, and the practice itself was not properly characterized. That choice reinforces the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable. Totem poles serve a specific cultural purpose and should not be a punchline.”
They were right in saying further that editors were responsible for what we choose to publish. The old English idiom, “Low man on the totem pole,” is actually incorrect. In many Pacific Northwest First Nations and Native American traditions, the low man is often the most revered.
“Readers deserve political commentary that holds public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures,” the statement continued.
In summary, here is what the group asked us to do:
- Publish an apology in print and online that names the racist stereotypes in the cartoon and take responsibility for it.
- Explain how the cartoon was approved.
- Provide opportunities to educate staff onthe Indigenous community.
- Seek and utilize resources provided by IJA and other journalism organizations.
Here is our reaction: We will not apologize for our cartoonist’s point of view. Asking tough questions about our state’s future is our job. Trever’s commentary came from a place of civic concern, not prejudice.
But we do regret that we as editors did not think more deeply about the cultural ramifications of the language used to make that point. We will learn from that.
We also will reach out to the Indigenous Journalists Association to learn more about their newsroom training resources.
“New Mexico and the Southwest are home to many Native communities and Indigenous people are among the Journal’s readers, sources and neighbors. They deserve the same care, accuracy and respect that every community should expect from its newspaper,” the group said in closing its statement.
I also contacted Stacey Lee, a Journal Community Council member and a member of the Navajo Nation. She said each tribe has its own traditions, and many are sacred.
“The cartoon has a character speak to Gov.-elect Haaland using a tradition that belongs to a different Indigenous people,” Lee said. “To me, that suggests the speaker does not respect who she is and it comes across as belittling. More than that, it shows a habit of grouping all Indigenous people together as one, which is not the correct way to see us. Each tribe is its own nation with its own identity.”
Lee encouraged us to consider having someone from the Indigenous community review content like this before publication.
“Many people simply do not know how sacred these traditions are. Sharing that understanding can make this a teaching moment for our whole community, and I would welcome that conversation,” the Albuquerque banker added.
Through the years, I have lived in states with large Native American communities — from Arizona to Oklahoma and now New Mexico. I have covered everything from cultural events to elections and sporting events.
I thought I knew more than I really did.
Indigenous people are our leaders, friends, neighbors and readers. They deserve better from me as an editor.
The link to the Journal Bennett column is here
https://www.abqjournal.com/news/bennett-addressing-haaland-editorial-cartoon-concerns/3162165
NOT THE FIRST TIME
This is not the first-time controversy over a political editorial cartoon published by the Albuquerque Journal has sparked controversy and a demand for an apology from the paper.
On February 7, 2018, the Albuquerque Journal published on its editorial page an inflammatory political cartoon by national syndicated political cartoonist Sean Delonas depicting a frightened white couple holding their hands up in the air apparently being robbed by two MS-13 gang members pointing a gun at the couple, and depicting a terrorist strapped with lighted bomb fuses and holding a bloody machete.
The man is quoted telling his wife: “Now Honey … I believe they prefer to be called ‘Dreamers’ … or future Democrats …”
The cartoon sent the clear, false and inflammatory message that all dreamers and Democrats are criminal gang members and terrorists willing to kill or commit suicide to kill. The cartoon was swiftly condemned by readers and elected officials, both Republican and Democrat, as being “misguided”, “bigoted”, and described as an example of “ignorance, racism and hatred”.
A protest erupted over the cartoon at the Journal Center and others called for people to cancel their Albuquerque Journal subscriptions. Within two days, the Albuquerque Journal issued an apology and said it would better screen political cartoons it publishes on its editorial page.
Then Albuquerque Journal Editor Karen Moses said the cartoon was “poking at President Trump’s rhetoric” and said this:
“In hindsight, instead of generating debate, this cartoon only inflamed emotions. This was not the intent, and for that, the Journal apologizes. … I also want to reiterate that we do not agree with many of the opinions expressed on the editorial pages, which are intended to encourage debate. Also, the editorial board decides what to publish on these pages, and that is separate from the newsroom and its reporters.”
In describing the Journal’s rationale for choosing to publish the cartoon, then Editorial Page Editor D’ Val Westphal said “the mission of an editorial page is to explore all sides of an issue, to make people think and debate and examine closely the opposing view of an argument. Unfortunately, this cartoon did not inspire that kind of discussion.”
The Albuquerque Journal’s apology was viewed by many as an effort to control the damage and lacking sincerity and somewhat hollow.
https://www.politico.com/story/2018/02/09/albuquerque-journal-apologizes-cartoon-400997
COMMENTARY AND ANALYIS
A regret is no apology. It is always very difficult for anyone to admit they are wrong and that they have made a major mistake doing their job. It’s even more difficult for management to apologize for the actions of an employee and take full responsibility. It appears to be especially so when you’re the very new managing editor of the state’s largest newspaper and you consider the paper you work for as the “paper of record” for the community. Such is the case with Albuquerque Journal’s managing editor James Bennett’s November 14 column expressing regret for publishing the cartoon with no apology.
The paper’s managing editor James Bennett is known to be a very prolificate writer since being hired by the Albuquerque Journal eight months ago in April, 2026 as the managing editor. Many of Bennett’s columns appear on the front page of the Albuquerque Journal with his photo and top of the fold banner headlines. However, his editorial opinion column entitled “Addressing Haaland editorial cartoon concerns” was published on a Saturday, when readership is likely low, on last page A-10 at and below the fold. One has to wonder why it was not on the Albuquerque Journal front page with a banner headline on a Sunday when readership is likely higher?
Although buried on page A-10 of the Journal, Bennett’s opinion column was defiant when he wrote “we will not apologize for our cartoonist’s point of view” and then he acknowledges that editors are responsible for what they choose to publish. Bennett came close to an apology when he wrote “I thought I knew more than I really did. Indigenous people are our leaders, friends, neighbors and readers. They deserve better from me as an editor.”
FIRST AMENDMENT FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
Under the United States Constitution First Amendment guarantees of freedom of speech and of the press, the Albuquerque Journal had every right to publish Trevor’s political cartoon on its editorial page, but that does not mean it should have published it. Just because one has the right to free speech does not mean you should “mouth off” inflammatory opinions to get a rise out of people. The Trevor cartoon was viewed as racist, degrading and inflammatory by many readers. The Journal editors should not have published it in the first place.
John Trevor is celebrating 50 years as the Albuquerque Journal editorial cartoonist. By publishing the Trevor cartoon, like it or not by the editors, it became an editorial endorsement by the Journal. Bennett admitted as much when he wrote “Trever’s weekly cartoon was similar to a column I wrote the morning after the election celebrating the historic nature of Haaland’s victory. … [The only difference is] I did not use a throwaway line about a totem pole as a punch line.”
Publishing the cartoon reflected poor judgment or lack of common sense by the editors. The editors should have been more sensitive to the racist overtones and what was said on social media during the 2026 New Mexico Governor’s election. Throughout the 2026 election process, hostility, and outright racism and slurs were thrown at Deb Haaland on social media, especially by the Republican MAGA crowd, as they degraded Haaland, questioned her intelligence despite her two college degrees, questioned her competency and the positions she has held and her accomplishments. Governor Elect Haaland simply ignored the hate, the racism and slurs as she campaigned as did the overwhelming majority New Mexico voters. Deb Haaland won and made history by becoming first Native American ever elected governor with a 57% to 43% victory over her Republican opponent.
Over the next four years, the Albuquerque Journal and John Trevor no doubt will have more than a few opportunities, and will take them, to criticize Governor Deb Haaland. She has not even been sworn into office, and the Journal should have resisted one last opportunity to be critical of her before she is sworn in on January 1, 2027 which will be a truly historic accomplishment with the election of the first ever Native American as New Mexico Governor.
____________________________
POSTSCRIPT
On Sunday November 15, the Albuquerque Journal in its SPEAKUP! Opinion section published the following comment sent by PETE DINELLI:
“Regarding the editorial cartoon published in the Nov. 9 Sunday Journal. The cartoon was racist, showing a N.M. cowboy with a frown looking down on the first-ever NATIVE AMERICAN WOMAN ELECTED GOVERNOR using the term “totem pole.” The Albuquerque Journal editors know better and should be more sensitive to New Mexico’s diverse culture and apologize.” PD